Sun K.

asked • 06/08/13

Find the volume?

Find the volume of the solid ball x^2+y^2+z^2<=1.

Steve F.

All of the ways you all derived the formula for volume of a sphere are correct. However the way the question was posed did not (to me) imply that they were looking for a calculus derivation. If the professor were, I feel that the problem would be stated as follows " Derive the formula for volume of a spehere with radius r= 1 by rotating a semicircal (y = sqrt(1-x^2))  around the x-axis." In this problem it was just stated that the formula for the sphere was x^2 + y^2 + z^2 = 1. This is exactly the formula of a shpere of raduius 1. The volume of the sphere is V = 4/3 pi r ^3 so just plug in r=1. But I did like all that calculus! But I say no need to drive from Boston to florida by going to california first. (unless you enjoy the scenery!)

Report

06/09/13

Nataliya D.

Steve, in general, you are perfectly right!!!! But, if somebody learn AP Calculus or college Calculus (that what I assume from all his questions) they have to approach and solve the problem by using the formulas on the level of that subject. People, who vote down for the answers, just don't understand the process/level of teaching.All three answers are perfectly legitimate!!! But if student in my Geometry class will use integral to solve this kind of problem he/she will get zero+ (+ for nice try) ....
If in ballet class ballerina will dance "Viennese Waltz" the way regular people dance and not on tiptoes, it will be not accepted.

P.S. I never answered on Sun's questions, because I knew that at least 2 tutors (Robert and Roman) can do it much-much-much better than I can do, on the level of Calculus.

Report

06/09/13

Steve F.

Hi, Nataliya.

Thanks for your input. I do appreciate what you are saying. My voting "down" was in no way supposed to be interpreted as any disrespect. I do applaud there calculus approach to the problem. I will refrain from the voting down button to express myself. I only voted down 

Report

06/10/13

Steve F.

Hi, Nataliya.

Thanks for your input. I do appreciate what you are saying. My voting "down" was in no way supposed to be interpreted as any disrespect. I do applaud there calculus approach to the problem. I will refrain from the voting down button to express myself. I only voted down 

Report

06/10/13

Steve F.

Hi, Nataliya.

Thanks for your input. I do appreciate what you are saying. My voting "down" was in no way supposed to be interpreted as any disrespect. I do applaud there calculus approach to the problem. I will refrain from the voting down button to express myself. I only voted down 

Report

06/10/13

Steve F.

Hi, Nataliya.

Thanks for your input. I do appreciate what you are saying. My voting "down" was in no way supposed to be interpreted as any disrespect. I do applaud there calculus approach to the problem. I will refrain from the voting down button to express myself. I only voted down 

Report

06/10/13

Steve F.

Hi, Nataliya.

Thanks for your input. I do appreciate what you are saying. My voting "down" was in no way supposed to be interpreted as any disrespect. I do applaud there calculus approach to the problem. I will refrain from the voting down button to express myself. I only voted down 

Report

06/10/13

Steve F.

..to signify that I felt there was an easier way to approach the problem.. The problem did not state to use calculus.. the problem even gave the formula for the equation of a sphere..at any rate my apologies... Again I do applaud their calculus approach!

Report

06/10/13

Steve F.

Thanks, Nataliya.. I will heed your advice. I guess thats why they dont have a "dislike" button on Facebook! :-)  

 

steve

Report

06/11/13

3 Answers By Expert Tutors

By:

Robert J. answered • 06/09/13

Tutor
4.6 (13)

Certified High School AP Calculus and Physics Teacher

Steve F. answered • 06/08/13

Tutor
5 (1)

Need Math Help? I'm the One for You!

Nataliya D.

Oh no, no, no, Steve, you don't have to apologize!! "Disrespect" even did not cross my mind!! We all have rights to express our opinion, fortunately, this is America ... :) I just felt frustration in your note .... and wrote mine ... we need to dispute our disagreements.
Personally, I vote up if I like the answer and never voted down if don't like.
Thank you, Steve :)

Report

06/10/13

Still looking for help? Get the right answer, fast.

Ask a question for free

Get a free answer to a quick problem.
Most questions answered within 4 hours.

OR

Find an Online Tutor Now

Choose an expert and meet online. No packages or subscriptions, pay only for the time you need.