Kailyn G.

asked • 05/20/24

Find probablilty give Probablitlies

This season, the probability that the Yankees will win a game is 0.61 and the probability that the Yankees will score 5 or more runs in a game is 0.49. The probability that the Yankees lose and score fewer than 5 runs is 0.3. What is the probability that the Yankees will lose when they score 5 or more runs? Round your answer to the nearest thousandth.


3 Answers By Expert Tutors

By:

Raymond B. answered • 05/20/24

Tutor
5 (2)

Math, microeconomics or criminal justice

Patrick F.

tutor
The question is not asking for the intersection of losing and scoring more than 5 runs. It is asking for the probability of loss given that they score more than 5 runs. It is a conditional probability and Bayes Thm should be used.
Report

05/20/24

Patrick F.

tutor
There are no ties in baseball :)
Report

05/20/24

James S.

tutor
Really?
Report

05/20/24

James S.

tutor
Severe weather can force a game to end in a tie.
Report

05/20/24

James S.

tutor
The problem is poorly worded, perhaps due to the student. But as stated, 0.09 is the correct answer.
Report

05/20/24

Patrick F.

tutor
"Severe weather can force a game to end in a tie." That is not true. Game will resume when the weather clears, could be another day.
Report

05/21/24

Patrick F.

tutor
So then what is the probability that they win when they score more than 5 runs? .91? When they score more than 5 runs they either win or lose, right? Please just have a look at your logic. We should try to give this student a clear answer.
Report

05/21/24

James S.

tutor
Please read the problem. Where is a condition stated? If asks for a joint probability, the occurrence of two events.
Report

05/21/24

Patrick F.

tutor
OK, so when the Yankees score 5 or more runs, what is the probability that they win?
Report

05/21/24

James S.

tutor
Why don't you check on MLB history before you make false statements?
Report

05/21/24

James S.

tutor
The student should be given a clear statement of the problem, not an ambiguous one.
Report

05/21/24

James S.

tutor
If you are not going to script your videos, why bother doing them? You end up rambling along, taking far more time than necessary.
Report

06/11/24

Patrick F.

tutor
There seems to be some controversy on this question. First is the issue of ties. There are no ties in the sport of baseball. "But", someone might say, "what if an asteroid lands on the stadium, while the score is tied, and all players of each team are killed? Surely that would end in a tie!" I think we can ignore those scenarios for the purpose of this question. Second, there seems to be some confusion about the word "when". If I ask this question: "What happens when the Yankees score 5 or more runs?" The answer is clear: They win; or they lose. This is exactly the same as saying: "given that they score 5 or more runs what happens". I think it is clear that this is a conditional probability, therefore Bayes Theorem should be used.
Report

05/21/24

James S.

tutor
"The last time an MLB game ended in a tie was back in 2016 when the Pirates and Cubs had to abandon their contest after severe weather conditions hindered play." Not frequent, but not non-existent. No asteroid involved.
Report

05/21/24

James S.

tutor
The sentence immediately before your "when" reads: "The probability that the Yankees lose and score fewer than 5 runs is 0.3" The word "and" is in initalics. If the problem hinges on "when", why wasn't it also emphasized?
Report

05/21/24

Patrick F.

tutor
This is not correct. The question asks for a conditional probability and so Bayes theorem should be used. Have a look at my solution.
Report

05/20/24

James S.

tutor
As stated, my answer is correct. The problem is poorly worded, perhaps due to the student. Where does the problem statement state that something was given or had previously happened?
Report

05/20/24

Patrick F.

tutor
"When" is not at all the same as "and". Think of it this way, when they score more than 5 runs they either win or lose, right? OK, so would you now say that the probability that they win when they score more than 5 runs is .91? Surely not. Let's try to clarify this to the student.
Report

05/21/24

Patrick F.

tutor
When the Yankees score 5 or more runs, what is the probability that they win?
Report

05/21/24

James S.

tutor
You are changing the wording of the sentence. You wouldn't need to do that if you were correct.
Report

05/21/24

James S.

tutor
"Think of it this way"? Don't you mean, "Think of it my way?"
Report

05/21/24

Patrick F.

tutor
What is the probability that the Yankees will win when they score 5 or more runs? (exactly following language of question)
Report

05/21/24

James S.

tutor
Joe found a dollar when it was 3 pm. Not a conditional probability.
Report

05/22/24

Patrick F.

tutor
Can you just answer this: What is the probability that the Yankees will win when they score 5 or more runs? (exactly following language of question). This should be a very simple straight forward question. Just use the same logic you used for probability they lose.
Report

05/22/24

James S.

tutor
The Yankees lost the game WHEN it was 3 pm. Not a conditional probability. Your question has been answered.
Report

05/22/24

Patrick F.

tutor
If you actually answered my question in good faith, then you might learn something. But if you want to double down on your interpretation, then no worries.
Report

05/22/24

Still looking for help? Get the right answer, fast.

Ask a question for free

Get a free answer to a quick problem.
Most questions answered within 4 hours.

OR

Find an Online Tutor Now

Choose an expert and meet online. No packages or subscriptions, pay only for the time you need.