Marcin K. answered 01/05/23
Tutoring in JavaScript, Web Development, Physics and Math
Hi Tasneem,
Let's start by looking at some relevant equations for the Volume (V) and Surface Area (A) of a sphere:
V = 4/3 * π * r3
A = 4 * π * r2
* Side note, the Area equation is a derivative of the Volume equation! dV/dr = 4 * π * r2
The problem gives us a rate of change of -4π cm2/s for the area, and is asking us for the rate of change of the volume. So, we are given the derivative of Surface Area relative to time, dA/dt. We are looking for dV/dt. We are also given the radius (r) at that moment.
Since we don't have equations for the Area or Radius in terms of time, we want to modify them to something we do have - the radius, which we are given in the problem and our useful equations! So, we'll relate the rates of change of the Area and Volume in terms of the change of the radius:
dA/dt = dA/dr * dr/dt
dV/dt = dV/dr * dr/dt
We will rearrange these for our first approach:
(dA/dt)/(dA/dr) = dr/dt
(dV/dt)/(dV/dr) = dr/dt
dA/dr is the derivative of 4 * π * r2, which we find to be 8 * π * r. dV/dr is the derivative of 4/3 * π * r3, which we know is the same as A: 4 * π * r2.
At this point, we can fill in the derivatives with what we know:
dA/dt = -4π cm2/s (given)
dA/dr = 8π * r, and given r = 2, dA/dr = 8*2*π, or 16π cm.
dV/dr = 4π * r2, and given r = 2, dV/dr = 4*4*π, or 16π cm2.
Since we know (dA/dt)/(dA/dr) = dr/dt and (dV/dt)/(dV/dr) = dr/dt, we can set the two sides of the equations equal to eachother:
(dA/dt)/(dA/dr) = (dV/dt)/(dV/dr)
Filling in, we get:
(-4π)/(16π) = (dV/dt)/(16π), which results in: dV/dt = -4π cm3/s.
So our final answer is -4π cm3/s.
Another way to conceptualize this from the halfway point:
dA/dt = dA/dr * dr/dt
dV/dt = dV/dr * dr/dt
We can find dA/dr by deriving A = 4 * π * r2, which gives us dA/dr = 8π * r. Plugging in r = 2 here, we get dA/dr = 16π.
Since we know dA/dt (given) as 4π, we can solve for dr/dt:
-4π = 16π * dr/dt
and find that dr/dt = -1/4.
Then, we can plug that into our second equation:
dV/dt = dV/dr * -1/4
and we can find dV/dr by deriving V = 4/3 * π * r3, which becomes dV/dr = 4 * π * r2. Plugging in for r = 2, we find dV/dr = 16π: And that leaves our equation as:
dV/dt = 16π * -1/4 = -4π.
You can follow the units through the equations to see that the final answer is -4π cm3/s.
Marcin K.
Hey, no problem! I'm also having trouble understanding the steps you mentioned, but doing my best: V = 4/3 π r^3 A = 4 π r^2 To express V in terms of A, we first express r in terms of A: r = sqrt(A / 4π) V = 4/3 π (sqrt(A / 4π))^3, or: V = 4/3 π (A / 4π)^(3/2) If we substitute r = 2 in our A equation, we get A = 16π. This is the value at the time t when r = 2, or the value of A(t0) at time t0. This looks like a chain rule situation - f(g(x)): df/dx = f'(g(x)) * g'(x) Let's set our f(x) to 4/3 π (g(x))^3/2, and our g(x) = A(t) / 4π. Our f'(x) = 2π (g(x))^(1/2), our g(x) = A(t) / 4π, and g'(x) = A'(t) / 4π. Plugging things in to f'(g(x)) * g'(x), we get: V' = 2π (A(t) / 4π)^(1/2) * (A'(t) / 4π). We can now plug in the values of A(t) and A'(t) at our given moment, t0. A(t0) is 16π as we calculated earlier, and A'(t0) is the given rate of change, -4π. Therefore: dV/dt = 2π * sqrt(16π / 4π) * (-4π / 4π) = 2π * sqrt(4) * (-1) = -4π This is, unfortunately, the same answer I gave before... I hope that was of some help.01/05/23
Marcin K.
Sorry, my formatting got deleted. I hope it's still somewhat legible.01/05/23
Tasneem Z.
Yeah, it's alright. Despite getting the same answer, at least, her steps were used. Thank you very much for your guidance.01/06/23
Tasneem Z.
Thank you for answering the question. I genuinely appreciate it. So that you know I got the answer the same as yours which is -4π but then my lecturer told me that the answer was wrong and it was not -4π. (She didn't tell me the correct answer though) She particularly told me that I didn't express the volume, V in terms of A. In addition, she told me to use her steps which are: Step 1: She just told us to list all the necessary formulas related to the question. volume= 4/3 π r^3 area= 4 π r^2 radius= 2 Step 2: Then express V in terms of A Step 3: substitute r, r=2 Step 4: Differentiate with respect to t She told me to use her steps yet I still can't figure out the answer. Especially, when it comes to the fourth step. I hope you can help me solve this question. Thank you01/05/23