David R.
asked • 09/17/22Are there situations where a definite article is optional? How can I recognize such a situation?
In the sentence "Is the book heavy?" the definite article is required. In the sentence "If you have the time, look here." the definite article seems to be optional. Why is that? How would one know when a definite article is optional?
More
2 Answers By Expert Tutors
Karen T. answered • 09/17/22
Tutor
5.0
(434)
Exceptionally Friendly Math, English, and Science Tutor
Hi, David,
"The" is a definite article because it tells us about a specific or particular noun (person, place, thing, or idea).
When the noun names something we don't count, (like rice, water, money or time) we can omit it.
Here are some examples of where we can use "the" or omit it:
Can I have the rice for dinner? or Can I have rice for dinner?
We found the water. or We found water.
He has the money. or He has money.
Do you have the time for a movie? or Do you have time for a movie?
I hope this helps!
Best, Karen
David R.
Karen, Thank you.In the first three examples, I think there are slightly different meanings depending on whether "the" is included.or omitted. With the inclusion of "the", it is a reference to some specific rice, water, or money. With the omission of "the", it is a reference to rice, water, or money in general, rather than some specific rice, water, or money.
I received another answer by EMail. I copied it into a comment to the question (which can be opened by clicking "Comment" immediately below the question).
It seems to me that using a definite article makes reference to a specific thing and omitting a definite article makes reference to a thing of that type, but not to a specific one. There are a number of contexts in which a reference to a specific thing or to a non-specific one both make sense, so including or omitting a definite article are both grammatically correct, but their meanings are a little different.
Karen gives good examples of sentences with and without a definite article (that is, situations where both specific references and non-specific references are reasonable, so both the inclusion or omission a definite article would be correct).
Here are some examples where the context implies a reference to a specific thing and hence a definite article is required.
You overcooked the rice.
Turn off the water.
I counted the money in my wallet.
She took a new job because the money was better.
Leave when the time is right.
When the game ended, the time was ten o'clock.
Right now, the time is ten o'clock.
Thank you again for your help.
Report
09/18/22
Raymond B. answered • 09/17/22
Tutor
5
(2)
Math, microeconomics or criminal justice
The "ABC's" of writing are Accuracy, Brevity, Clarity. Number 2, B = Brevity, would call for dropping the article if it adds little or nothing. Two ways of saying something, go with the Briefer. That's the purpose of language to communicate in words that don't require a lengthy wordy verbose rambling that puts people to sleep. But not so brief as to lose Clarity or Accuracy.
Also, "'The' time" seems to refer to a specific actual time period. "a Time" or Just "time" is more general.
"If you have time, look here" doesn't seem to refer to any specific time period, just whenever you may have time. he is The President refers to a specific president "A President" is more general and could refer to 46 different presidents. "Yo' The Man," means you're special, the Big Cheese. "You are a man" just says you're an XY but these days not even that, and probably a homo sapien or at least a warm blooded mammal.
Online everything gets abbreviated for text messages. "The" is out the door. so is "a"
then there's the evolving English language, where you go with the flow, and do whatever everyone is doing. We no longer speak the King's English.
Or ee. cummings, the poet ignoring all grammar conventions. You can get away with most anything if people understand minimally the essence of what you're saying. Spanish speakers understand Italian, and without regard to grammar, articles or other linguistic technicalities or niceties.
David R.
Thank you Raymond. i received an abbreviated version of your answer by EMail, but I didn't know who the author was. Since that answer wasn't shown on this web page, I included it in a comment attached to the question.Karen makes some interesting points in her answer. You might want to look at some examples that I came up with and included in a comment on Karen's answer.
Report
09/20/22
Still looking for help? Get the right answer, fast.
Ask a question for free
Get a free answer to a quick problem.
Most questions answered within 4 hours.
OR
Find an Online Tutor Now
Choose an expert and meet online. No packages or subscriptions, pay only for the time you need.
David R.
I received another answer by EMail. I don't know who wrote it or why it wasn't posted to this web page. Here it is:- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
The "ABC's" of writing are Accuracy, Brevity, Clarity. Number 2, B = Brevity, would call for dropping the article if it adds little or nothing. Two ways of saying something, go with the Briefer. That's the purpose of language to communicate in words that don't require a lengthy wordy verbose rambling that puts people to sleep.
Also, "'The' time" seems to refer to a specific actual time period. "a Time" or Just "time" is more general.
"If you have time, look here" doesn't seem to refer to any specific time period, just whenever you may have time.
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
With respect to the last sentence, to me, "If you have the time" is equivalent to "If you have time now".
09/18/22