Dr. Andy T. answered 08/24/20
UT Austin Ph.D. in Physics and Certified Math Teacher at Top STEM HS
Hi Aktug,
Any max/min/saddle points must occur at a critical point, which is a point where both partial derivatives are equal to 0 (in general, we also need to consider points where at least one of the partial derivatives fails to exist, but since your function is a polynomial the partial derivatives exist everywhere).
The partial derivatives are fx = y2 + 6x2 + 10x and fy = 2y + 2xy. To find the critical points, we therefore need to find all possible solutions to the following system of equations:
y2 + 6x2 + 10x = 0 (1)
2y + 2xy = 0 (2)
The second equation factorizes as 2y(1+x) = 0, so this holds if y = 0 or x = -1. We now separately plug these into the first equation.
If y = 0, then the first equation becomes 6x2 + 10x = 0 or 2x(3x + 5) = 0, which holds if x = 0 or x = - 5/3. This means that (x,y) = (0,0), (-3/5, 0) are critical points.
Now suppose x = -1. Then the first equation becomes
y2 + 6 - 10 = 0
y2 - 4 = 0
(y+2)(y-2) = 0
which has solution y = -2 or y = 2. This means that (x,y) = (-1,-2), (-1,2) are also critical points.
We now need to classify each of the critical points (x,y) = (0,0), (-3/5, 0), (-1,-2), (-1,2) that we found above.
This is done using the second partial derivatives as follows. First compute the function
D = fxx fyy - (fxy)2
and evaluate it at each critical point. Then
- If D > 0 and fxx > 0, the critical point is a relative min.
- If D > 0 and fxx < 0, the critical point is a relative max.
- If D < 0, then the critical point is a saddle point.
- If D = 0, the test is indeterminate, and we need to use other techniques to classify the critical point.
Since the second partial derivatives are fxx = 12x + 10, fyy = 2x + 2, fxy = 2y, the function D is given by
D = (12x + 10)(2x + 2)-(2y)2.
Let's now investigate each critical point:
- At (x,y) = (0,0), D = 20>0 and fxx = 10>0, so (0,0) is a relative min.
- At (x,y) = (-3/5,0), D = 56/25 >0 and fxx = 14/5>0, so (-3/5,0) is a relative min.
- At (x,y) = (-1,-2), D = -16 < 0, so (-1,-2) is a saddle point.
- At (x,y) = (-1,2), D = -16 < 0, so (-1,2) is a saddle point.
I hope this helps!
Dr. Andy T.
That was a typo. It is -5/3. Good catch!08/26/20
Aktug Y.
Thanks for answer, but i have 1 more question. If y = 0, then the first equation becomes 6x2 + 10x = 0 or 2x(3x + 5) = 0, which holds if x = 0 or x = - 5/3. This means that (x,y) = (0,0), (-3/5, 0) are critical points. Why did we converted -5/3 to -3/5 ?08/26/20