Ask a question

A student chooses a red marble from a Bag and Then chooses another red marble without replacing the first. is it independent or dependent ?

Is this independent or dependent ? 

1 Answer by Expert Tutors

Tutors, sign in to answer this question.
TrungThanh B. | Math and Science TutorMath and Science Tutor
5.0 5.0 (12 lesson ratings) (12)
Let say you have 10 marbles in the bag. 5 are blue and 5 are red.
First draw: if you want a red marble, you have 5 out of 10 chances to get it.
Second draw: since you dont put the first red marble back, it is not accounted for. So when you reach in the bag, you only have 4 out 9 chances of getting another red marble. 
So we can see clearly that the outcome of the 1st draw affects the out come of the 2nd draw; and hence it is dependent


No it is not:
  Let's take your assumption that there are 10 marbles of red and Blue 5 of each
  A - first draw be red
  B - 2nd draw be red ,then:
   Probability of 2nd draw to be red:
    A . B + A. B
    1/2 . 5/9 + 1/2 .4/9 = 5/18 + 4/ 18 = 9/18 = 1/2
     So the Probability of drawing Red marble without replacements is first draw or 2nd draw is the same 1/2.
     therefore the events are independent.
    probabilty Drawing