Cookies and cream I.
asked 07/10/23How do you solve this vector word problem?
An airplane ends up 540 miles and 20 degrees north of east from its departure point. If there was a steady wind of 30 mph from the northwest during the entire flight, then find the magnitude and direction that the plane would have gone if there had been no wind.
2 Answers By Expert Tutors
AJ L. answered 07/11/23
Supportive K-12 + College Math Tutor
The airplane as a vector would be --> a =〈540cos(20),540sin(20)〉
The wind as a vector would be --> w =〈30cos(135),30sin(135)〉
The resultant vector would be --> a+w =〈540cos(20)+30cos(135), 540sin(20)+30sin(135)〉
Finding the magntiude would be ||a+w|| = √[[540cos(20)+30cos(135)]2+[540cos(20)+30cos(135)]2] ≈ 528.02
The direction would be θ = tan-1(w/a) = tan-1([540sin(20)+30sin(135)]/[540cos(20)+30cos(135)]) ≈ 22.95º
Hope this helped!
Dayv O.
do you agree that a is in units of miles, and w in units of miles per hour? If time was specified as 1 hour then can add vectors as specified in your answer if wind direction made correct.07/11/23
Dayv O.
wind from north is -90 degrees vector, wind from west is 0 degree vector. wind from northwest is -45 degrees, true?07/11/23
AJ L.
Since the 30mph wind was constant throughout the entire trip, then the speed of the airplane must also be constant. So, the speed of the plane is 540mph.07/11/23
Dayv O.
agree speed of airplane is constant. I do not agree trip took one hour. Is it some piece I am missing that flight took one hour?07/11/23
AJ L.
The problem never mentioned that the flight took an hour. Time has nothing to do with the result of the problem.07/11/23
Dayv O.
If trip is specified as being one hour, then fly plane at 528 mph at 22.9 degrees to reach 540 miles at 22 degrees when wind is 30 mph at -45 degrees., if trip is specified as being 10 hours, then fly plane at 49.4 mph at 53.3 degrees to reach 540 miles at 22 degrees with 30 mph wind at -45 degrees. In the ten hour case, if there was no wind, plane after ten hours would be 494 miles at 53.3 degrees.07/11/23
Dayv O.
If trip is specified as being one second, then fly plane at 1.944 million mph at 22 degrees.07/11/23
Dayv O. answered 07/10/23
Caring Super Enthusiastic Knowledgeable Trigonometry Tutor
can say
rcos(θ)+(30t)cos(pi/4)=540cos(pi/9)
rsin(θ)-(30t)sin(pi/4)=540sin(pi/9)
r is distance and θ heading with east as zero
of plane without wind. pi/9<θ<10pi/9
r(cos(θ)+sin(θ))=540(cos(pi/9)+sin(pi/9))
if θ=pi/2,,,,r=540(cos(pi/9)+sin(pi/9))
if θ=pi/4,,,,r=(270√2)(cos(pi/9)+sin(pi/9))
another way to look at problem is to fill in how much time the trip took (missing in description)
If trip is specified as being one hour, then fly plane at 528 mph at 22.9 degrees to reach 540 miles at 22 degrees when wind is 30 mph at -45 degrees., if trip is specified as being 10 hours, then fly plane at 49.4 mph at 53.3 degrees to reach 540 miles at 22 degrees with 30 mph wind at -45 degrees. In the ten hour case, if there was no wind, plane after ten hours would be 494 miles at 53.3 degrees.
note that in original answer provided,,,, r(cos(θ)+sin(θ))=540(cos(pi/9)+sin(pi/9)),,,,if 53.3 degrees is value of theta, then r=494. check.Now it is learned that the condition for r=494, theta=53.3 degrees is trip takes ten hours.
Dayv O.
without more information can only find r as a function of angle/headding.07/10/23
AJ L.
You misinterpreted the problem07/11/23
Dayv O.
things seem to check perfectly.07/11/23
Dayv O.
I think you misinterpreted problem, plane velocity vector multiplied by time PLUS wind velocity vector multiplied by time EQUALS 540 miles at 22 degrees. Not plane velocity vector points at 22 degrees. Again wind is from northwest, toward southeast=-45 degrees.07/11/23
AJ L.
If you look up the exact problem, you will see people have the same answer as me07/11/23
AJ L.
I think the problem is poorly worded though because it produces some ambiguity07/12/23
Dayv O.
looked up just like you said, answers that are like yours specify they assume problem means one hour to get to 540 miles, meaning, to reiterate if given trip is one hour THE RESUTANT VELOCITY per proper interpretation of problem, is 540 mph. Quite opposite of thinking the plane actual velocity is 540 mph, the magnitude of plane velocity is 528 mph as you kind of calculated.07/12/23
Dayv O.
have you ever worked around airports?07/12/23
Still looking for help? Get the right answer, fast.
Get a free answer to a quick problem.
Most questions answered within 4 hours.
OR
Choose an expert and meet online. No packages or subscriptions, pay only for the time you need.
Dayv O.
was there an elapsed time in problem?07/11/23