
Martin S. answered 04/29/21
Patient, Relaxed PhD Molecular Biologist for Science and Math Tutoring
Hi Mindy,
Having thought about this a bit, I realize there is another method to get the answer that has a couple of fewer steps. The key is still to get the radius and height of the cylinder as described before. The next step would be to calculate the void volume of the cylinder, the empty space inside, and subtract that from the total volume. What is left is the steel shell of the cylinder. To do that, once you have the radius and height of the cylinder, calculate the void volume using the formula V = hπr2 because the void volume is also a cylinder. For the dimensions of the void cylinder, use the dimensions of the shell minus 0.5 ft which is the thickness of the cylinder. So you formula would be Vvoid = (hshell -0.5) x π(rshell - 0.5)2.Subtracting that value from the given volume of the cylinder gives you the volume of steel, then use the conversion factors to determine the price.
Hope that helps.
Martin S.
For this application there is a problem with simply multiplying the surface area by the thickness to calculate the volume of steel. Weel, there are two problems. First, the side of the cylinder is circular, not a flat 2 dimensional surface. The curvature needs to be accounted for, and that is why the method to find that portion of the volume would require subtracting the void volume of the virtual internal cylinder. The other problem is that by simply using the surface area, the calculation does not take into account that there would be an overlap of volumes in the space where the side and the base meet. If that is not considered, then there is a portion of the volume that is duplicated. By specifying the thickness of the walls of the cylinder, this becomes a 3 dimensional problem, and to reach an accurate answer each part of the geometry needs to be addressed separately.04/29/21