History is full of examples where if the victor ignores or continues to grind down the vanquished after formal hostilities have ended, all you do is foster smoldering resentment and sow the seeds for the next war. Magnanimity and inclusion after the war turns this around and old enemies then have a way of turning into new allies in surprisingly short time frames. However, this is precisely what did NOT happen at the end of World War I. The Treaty of Versailles that ended World War I was a deeply, deeply hated and heavy boot on the neck of the Germans, mostly because the French and some other allies wanted it that way as punishment. Germany was stripped of some lands, the air force was disbanded, the Navy was gutted, the German economy crashed, and people starved in the streets of Berlin. In addition Germany was saddled with huge war reparations that had to be paid back over decades. This created smoldering resentment, especially among unemployed former German soldiers and when a fiery charismatic leader arose from those ranks, Adolf Hitler, people were willing to listen to what he had to say. 21 years later, it was back on again when Hitler attacks Poland. At the end of World War II, the Allies this time resolved to do things differently, mostly thanks to George Marshal. History records this was a wise choice. You should be able to take it from there.
Alisha A.
asked 06/24/19The Unites States should or should not have helped Germany recover from World War II?
Write five paragraph argumentative essay.
2 Answers By Expert Tutors
Jacob S. answered 07/10/19
Eager Math and History Tutor
Hello!
Well, I wont write the entire essay for you, but I will give you some good points which will hopefully act as food for thought!
So what was the entire reason WWII occurred? As in, what was the reason for the rise of Nazism, the takeover of the German state by Hitler, and the brutal war which followed? Well a portion of that answer is due to the rampant economic hardship Germany faced following the end of WWI. Therefore it was in the entire world's best interest to prevent such a thing from happening again.
An even better answer is this: the Soviet Union, and Stalin in particular. Stalin was known by both the US and the UK/France to be tyrannical and ambitious, a dangerous combination to anyone who knows history. More than that, he sought to claim as much of Europe as possible to establish satellite Soviet States (Poland, Hungary, Romania, Baltic States, Ukraine, etc.). Therefore, it was in the Allies' best interest to rebuild the German state as quickly as possible to help combat Soviet expansion, and discourage Stalin from attempting to grasp more land.
You should also look into "Operation Unthinkable" in which the Allies had a plan to invade the Soviet Union following the end of WWII. Part of this plan involved restarting the German war machine, and unleashing it against the Soviets. Before this plan could proceed the Soviets developed their own nuclear weapons (or more accurately were able to steal the technology from the US) and such a war between two nuclear powers thus became unthinkable (get it?).
Anyway, that is a bit of information for you. I highly recommend to look into all of what I said, do your own research, and come to your own conclusions in a much more articulate way!
Kind regards,
Jacob S.
Still looking for help? Get the right answer, fast.
Get a free answer to a quick problem.
Most questions answered within 4 hours.
OR
Choose an expert and meet online. No packages or subscriptions, pay only for the time you need.