What is the name of this grammatical phenomenon?
2 Answers By Expert Tutors
Gary L. answered 06/24/19
The oral and written way people speak is often not interchangeable. Many people will write much better than they speak because they see writing as a more formalized way of communication that will be more heavily critiqued. At the same time spoken language is much more lax and people often use improper grammar when speaking because it sounds more fluid and is sometimes easier to say.
Naomi D. answered 06/24/19
This phenomenon is called psuedocleft, but the phrase usually begins with something like what, where, why or who and is meant to emphasize the 2nd half of the sentence, for example: What she is eating for lunch, is a hamburger. If the sentence starts with It, then the phenomenon is called a cleft.
Although I am sure you have heard them, I find the examples you have given to be grammatically incorrect or very awkward at best! The point of the double copula is also to emphasize the second half of the sentence, but it is wholly unnecessary! In my opinion, starting the sentence with a clause already gives the second half emphasis.
Here is how I would change your examples:
- That is what fascinated me about programming; it changes the way you think about the world. Or if you must make one a dependent clause of the other ... What fascinated me about programming, is that it changes the way you think about the world. [pseudocleft]
- Something we talk about a lot is the size of the community, which is substantially smaller than the React community Or It is the size of the community that is what we talk a lot about, which is substantially smaller than the React community. [cleft]
You can find more interesting terms and definitions here: https://ygdp.yale.edu/glossary
Still looking for help? Get the right answer, fast.
Get a free answer to a quick problem.
Most questions answered within 4 hours.
OR
Choose an expert and meet online. No packages or subscriptions, pay only for the time you need.
Duane J.
We don't always follow the strictest of rules when we speak as opposed to when we write. Occasionally, lapses in grammar like this happen when we are thinking of what we want to say and how to say it. Look at your example through a filter as I have described. The parentheses indicate thinking or lapses in word use and choice because they are thinking and speaking at the same time. (This is) Something we talk about a lot—is the size of the community (which) is substantially smaller than the React community The correctly planned sentence: "Something we talk about a lot is the size of the community which is substantially smaller than the React community." Bernie thinking and talking at the same time. He is answering the question but wants to repeat the question in his answer. "What I think went wrong... (AND THIS) is what (I THINK) Trump did very effectively ... (WHAT I THINK TRUMP DID) is tap the angst..." The correctly planned sentence: "This is what I think WENT wrong and what Trump DID very effectively WAS tap the angst..." When we speak "off the cuff" it is very easy to confuse incorrect grammar, context, hesitation, thought and breath groups. This is especially true because we don't use punctuation when we speak. Also, keep in mind to speak English coherently and concisely, it's not necessary to know every obscure grammar rule.06/24/19