Russ P. answered 01/08/15
Tutor
4.9
(135)
Patient MIT Grad For Math and Science Tutoring
Anna,
I see 2 errors, one trivial, the other major.
The trivial one is that the TSP filter weight difference is 18.12(4)9 g, not your 18.12(7)9 g.
The more serious error is that the problem asks for the "average" concentration, not the final concentration as you computed.
Hence average ΔW = 18.1249/2 = 9.06245 g/m3/24 hr.
Correcting both problems, I get 484.9 mg/m3/hr as the average TSP per hour per cubic meter.
Russ P.
Anna,
When the TSP unit is first set up, it has a clean filter. After 24 hours of operation it is dirty having trapped a lot of particles. The weight of the particles trapped over 24 hours is ΔW = (Wf - Wi). But ΔW(t),
if you plotted it, would look like a ramp starting at zero when TSP is installed and ending with the computed ΔW at 24 hours. However the problem asks for the average pollution which is ΔW(ave) = [ΔW(t=0) + ΔW(t=24)]/2
= [0 + ΔW]/2, irrespective of whether the caught particles follow a straight line buildup or have some curvatures as long as it keeps increasing with time. After all, during the first 12 hours the weight of the trapped particles is far below what
it is after 24 hours.
I got my figure using your formula that got you 969 erroneously because your numerator should have been the average value and not the ending value of ΔW. Just divide by 2.
You may be confused because you defined your TSP as average, but didn't use an average value of ΔW.
Report
01/08/15
Anna A.
01/08/15