J.R. S. answered 02/08/18
Tutor
5.0
(145)
Ph.D. University Professor with 10+ years Tutoring Experience
Don't let this concept "bug" you. As with everything in the scientific world, there are exceptions to every rule. I'll do my best to offer a plausible explanation, based on my somewhat limited knowledge of this exception to the octet "rule".
Metals like to donate electrons and so they tend not to have expanded octets even though they may have an empty d subshell. Non-metals that have a d-subshell are capable of having expanded octets. If, for example, you consider Al, Si, P, S and Cl, they all can have expanded octets. . You mention Xenon having 14 electrons and this can be true because Xe has an f subshell, and that has 7 orbitals. Since each orbital can hold 2 electrons, it can conceivably have 14 electrons.

J.R. S.
tutor
Again, the following explanation/answer is based on my limited understanding of the expanded octet. I think the reason that not just
any atom can use the d-orbital for an expanded octet is because some don't have available d orbitals, and also there are energy considerations, and finally the issue of "formal charge". In Lewis structures, it seems favorable to have the lowest formal charge on each atom, and if that may involve expanded octet. Elements (non metals) beyond the 3rd period have filled d orbitals, and the next orbital in line (as you put it) would be f. Again, whereas it may seem "possible" for electrons to begin to occupy the f subshell, (like the d before it), this does not seem to present an energetically favorable situation. I think there is still some debate as to exactly why expanded valence shells are found, and why they are more favorable than the situation that obeys the octet rule. You now know pretty much everything that I know.
Report
02/08/18
Mia D.
Ah okay, thanks for your help!
Report
02/09/18
Mia D.
02/08/18