I would agree that some of it is pure logic. Also, keep in mind that humans made up the symbols to fit what really already exists.
For instance, parenthesis is being used to represent something that has to be done first, i.e. what is outside those parenthesis is applied to the result of whatever is inside the parenthesis. So that's like saying I'm putting the parenthesis around something because I want that done first, versus I'm doing it first because there's parenthesis around it. Someone had to come up with a way to show that "this" thing needs done first, regardless of what symbol we use to do it with. That is, when I hand it to you, you have to know what I mean for you to do, so we both have to know the same rules.
For instance, if it's necessary to add 2 numbers together before taking the square of it, there has to be a way to show the adding comes first. If I write x + y^2, no one would know the adding needs done first unless we make a rule to indicate that. So what way can I indicate the adding comes first? (x + y)^2
Somewhere a decision was made that parenthesis would be used to indicate that. I want the square of the results of x + y, not just the square of y. This also leaves us with the fact that if I don't use those parenthesis, the square only belongs to the y, and then it means add x to the result of the square of y.
These are just examples but hopefully the point comes across.
I think it's probably important to keep in mind that in the end this is applied to real life situations where one thing actually needs to be done before another thing, and we need to have an agreed-upon way to show how it's supposed to be. So if I need a big set of things done, I have to make sure I use the appropriate symbols and using some set of rules, so that you would do it in the same manner.
Larry C.
This was not taught to me in any math class in the 1960s in Berkeley or Ann Arbor. I fail to find anyone on the internet willing to take the blame for inventing this mnemonic. It must have gained popularity after the introduction of calculators (which cannot follow these rules) and then the increased popularity of computer languages, which are required to follow such rules. It may be a good guide for writing a calculated string of expressions, but I always use parentheses and would never rely on a computer or a person figuring out what I meant.06/24/23