Inactive Tutor answered 01/02/16
Jack L.
asked 12/27/15Physic ( Battery work ? )
Dear teacher .
I have a question :
A battery has a negative end ( I dont know if end is a right word ? ) and a positive end .
From what i have heard that there was difference in amount of electrons between negative end and positive end , but battery is unlike ordinary object , electrons won't run from negative end to positive end ( chemical reason I Have heard ).
But what if I connect the negative end to neutral object , but leave the positive end untouch ( not connected ). Will the electron from negative end run into neutral object to equalize the amount of spare electrons ????
Hope you won't mind my bad English . Thanks
More
3 Answers By Expert Tutors
Tutor
New to Wyzant
I agree with Marshall O's response(s), but I also wanted to bring your attention to something else that I think you may be confusing.
An electrical circuit involves moving charges between two points of differing electrical potential (voltage). The voltage difference is what "pushes" the current flow through the circuit [Just like height differences (gravitational potential) and spring extension/compression (spring potential) drive other types of motion]. There does not have to be any charge imbalance present to move the electrons. Batteries, wires, resistors, etc are all electrically neutral--there is no excess charge within any of those objects.
Your idea of "equalizing the amount of spare electrons" when you touch down a single battery terminal doesn't happen simply because there are no spare electrons to equalize. Static electricity does not drive electrical currents
The chemicals inside a battery are designed to keep the two ends at different electrochemical potentials without disturbing the battery's overall electric charge.
Inactive Tutor answered 12/30/15
Tutor
New to Wyzant
The simple answer is no. To explain, electrons that can move do so when there is a difference in the electrical potential energy. A simple analogy is that a ball rolls downhill because the bottom of the hill has a lower gravitational potential energy compared to the top of the hill. If you connect one end of the battery (negative or positive, it does not matter which) to an electrically neutral object (I assume a metallic object), then the object has the same electrical potential energy as the battery connection. Since there is no difference in electrical potential energy, the electrons do not "move". You will see people say electrical current does not flow more often than saying electrons do not move, but the idea is the same. The two phrases use different words to express the same idea.
Inactive Tutor
As you know, people in the sciences try to avoid words such as "magically." Let me explain further. The key point is that electrical potential energy, like gravitational potential energy, has no single zero. So you and I can talk about the difference in electrical potential between the positive and negative terminals of a battery. We can say that this battery is 1.5 volts, and this other battery is 9.0 volts, and so forth. What we are saying is the difference. We are not saying that the negative terminal has a particular electrical potential, only the difference between the two terminals. So when I connect the negative terminal to an electrically neutral metallic object, the object has the same electrical potential as the negative terminal. Since there is no potential difference between the negative terminal and the object, no electrical current flows. However, there is a potential difference between the positive and negative terminals, so if they are connected to each other an electrical current will flow.
Report
12/30/15
Inactive Tutor
Of course "magically" isn't right scientific word - it's coming from your logic simply.
And, of course, again, the electric potentials are different from "neutral" ones, so, that when connecting a "neutral" wire to an end of electric battery, the wire will attract excess of electric charge - so, wire will be under similar potential as the corresponding end. Thus, the final answer to student's question is "Yes" which was posted days ago ...
Happy New Year.
P.S. and, don't bring any analogy with gravitational potentials - u aren't following your logic up to the end.
Report
12/31/15
Jack L.
Ok , so the final answer is yes right ?
So there must be electric current occur ? But difference in spare electrons between negative end and neutral object is so low that we hardly notice this electric current right . I just wonder if I understand correctly .
SO in capacitor will lose one of the plate's charge if it accidently connect to neutral object right ?
Report
01/01/16
Inactive Tutor answered 12/27/15
Tutor
New to Wyzant
Yes.
Still looking for help? Get the right answer, fast.
Ask a question for free
Get a free answer to a quick problem.
Most questions answered within 4 hours.
OR
Find an Online Tutor Now
Choose an expert and meet online. No packages or subscriptions, pay only for the time you need.
Inactive Tutor
12/30/15