Daniel O. answered 04/27/15
Tutor
4.9
(303)
Attorney and experienced teacher for LSAT Prep.
The height of the trees doesn't matter. the volume of a cylinder is (pi)(r^2)(h) (the area of the circle times the height). For each tree, that's 17 squared (radius is half of the diameter) times 28 cubic inches, or 8,092 cubic inches. That's a total of 32,368 cubic inches (since there are 4 trees).
Each bag holds (24)(18)(48) cubic inches of dirt (changing feet to inches by multiplying each dimension by 12), or 20,736 cubic inches. But only 1/3 of them is usable, so that's 6,912 cubic inches. To figure out the number of bags, divide the total amount of dirt (32,368) by the amount of dirt each bag holds (6,912). That doesn't come out evenly, but it doesn't have to - it's bigger than 4, but smaller than 5, so four bags won't do it, but five will. (A) is correct.
Daniel O.
Nope, you're not! I just dropped the pi when I did the calculation. Nice catch...you should get a prize or something; nobody else caught that in 4 1/2 years!
Report
12/02/19
Rudolph V.
You wrote: "The height of the trees doesn't matter. the volume of a cylinder is (pi)(r^2)(h) (the area of the circle times the height). For each tree, that's 17 squared (radius is half of the diameter) times 28 cubic inches, or 8,092 cubic inches. That's a total of 32,368 cubic inches (since there are 4 trees)." What happened to "pi"? If you take the 32,368 and multiply by 3.1417 you get 101,690.53 cu. in. therefore you need 14.7 bags, which makes 15 the correct answer. Am I missing something?12/02/19