a) Since all 3 consultants are chosen, we know Carl will be chosen. Now we only need to think about Elizabeth. There are C(8,5) total ways to choose 5 engineers from 8. This is the denominator. For the numerator there are C(1,1) ways to choose Elizabeth and C(7,4) to choose the other 4 members. [C(1,1) = 1]
So P = C(7,4)/C(8,5) = 5/8
b) The three consultants and Eddie are chosen leaving a total of C(7,4) for choosing 4 engineers from 7. In similar logic to a) the numerator is now C(6,3)
So P = C(6,3)/C(7,4) = 4/7