Michael L.

asked • 12/21/20

What is space? (Is space absolute or relational?)

2 Answers By Expert Tutors

By:

Cameron B. answered • 12/24/20

Tutor
4.8 (23)

Philosopher of Science with Machine Learning Experience.

Michael L.

Hello Cameron, thank you for your response. You've outlined the absolutist and relationist conceptions of space but you haven't defined space.
Report

12/25/20

Cameron B.

Hi Michael, I don't think there is just one answer to the question "what is space?". Or, there isn't a simple answer. You could classically say it is empty or a vacuum in-between massive bodies. If you read the SEP article, they also mention substantivalism---i.e. the claim that space is a substance in itself. Or you might have a more modern answer which gets into relativistic spacetimes, quantum field theory, or zero-point energy. There are philosophical, conceptual, as well as mathematical (e.g. Euclidean vs non-Euclidean geometries) involved in answering that question.
Report

12/26/20

Michael L.

I did read some of the article but I didn't understand much of the terminology.
Report

12/26/20

Michael L.

I am also interested in what your conception of space is.
Report

12/26/20

Cameron B.

Michael, at this point I think your interests would be best served by more intensive study of the foundations so that you are more familiar with the terminology and concepts used in articles like that. I'm not sure what your background or education level is, but if you are very interested in the philosophy and foundations of physics I can recommend going through Cushing's book Philosophical Concepts in Physics. Ideally, with a suitable tutor.
Report

12/26/20

Michael L.

Ok.
Report

01/11/21

Michael L.

The context in which I use the term space refers to an entity in which bodies are said to occupy.
Report

12/25/20

Lorraine T.

tutor
You need to define “bodies”.
Report

12/26/20

Michael L.

By 'bodies' I mean material objects.
Report

12/26/20

Lorraine T.

tutor
Which is made up of oscillating strings of energy that vibrates through space.
Report

12/26/20

Still looking for help? Get the right answer, fast.

Ask a question for free

Get a free answer to a quick problem.
Most questions answered within 4 hours.

OR

Find an Online Tutor Now

Choose an expert and meet online. No packages or subscriptions, pay only for the time you need.