Mr. Pink has contempt for much of humanity. You said "denies all claims that cannot be proved by evidence." but he is in the position of a blind man arguing with those who can see. Mr Pink is not treating Mr Black with the respect that an honest interlocutor should receive.
I would like to know Mr. Pink's moral life. Does he help the suffering? Does he bear other people's burdens?
The answer is , we have a MIND (which almost all questions such as yours emphasize) but we also have a Will -- the best you can do is give the Truth and leave it at that. You cannot force the Will