
Derek V. answered 03/27/19
Philosophy Professor with 5 years of Teaching Experience
"How would/could/should you consolidate hard determinism with responding to criminal acts?"
Suppose hard-determinism is true and moral responsibility requires free will and there is no free will. It follows that no convicted felon is morally blameworthy for what he or she does. Does this mean that it would wrong for non-felons to segregate the felons from society as a means to "rehabilitation" or at least damage control? I don't see how it would.