Hi Valerie,
We need to take a "weighted" average of the two isotopes to determine the atomic mass of the element.
Isotope AMU relative abundance
1 5.3731 75.5%
2 7.3904 24.5%
(5.3731 x .755) + (7.3904 x .245) = 4.0567 + 1.8106 = 5.8673
The atomic mass of the element is 5.8673