
Yuri O. answered 02/18/21
16 years online, 464 former SAT problems drilled down
First of all, let me address what you said: "Of the four choices, only choice (C), x = 5 + 3i, is a root value that is not a real number."
That's incorrect.
Note that answers 1, 3 and 4 - all - have non-real solutions of the quadratic equation: they all have "i" and "i" is an imaginary/complex number.
x = 5i or x = 3i → imaginary numbers
x = 5 + 3i → imaginary numbers
x = 5 - i or x = 5 + i → imaginary numbers
Answers 1, 2 and 4 give 2 solutions.
Answer 3 gives one solution.
We know that a quadratic equation may have one of two solutions - we assume that real or complex solutions are OK.
The question was, "Which of the answers could NOT be the entire solution?"
There is only one root in answer 3, and it may not be the entire solution of the quadratic equation.