
Christopher L. answered 07/17/19
Physics is fascinating when it is explained with real-life examples!!
Well you are not going wrong at all.
You are considering a single phenomenon and -
Like we all do -
We look for a single explanation for the truth.
However.
In many extraordinary cases - there are more than one model that explains things.
In light - we have the notion that light is well-understood - as a particle
But we also know that it is well-understood as a wave
Not only is neither incorrect - but both views are not just interesting but essential in our understanding
A less sophisticated example might be that when we look at an object thrown up in the air
We can solve this problem quite perfectly using the ol' s = (1/2)(at^2) + (v0)(t) + (s0) equation for motion
It all makes perfect sense
As an alternative - we can simultaneously solve these things via energies (kinetic and potential and conservation).
I teach physics - but even to this day - a part of me is surprised every time the answers agree to these things !
So the real answer to your dilemma - is that there is no dilemma ;-)
You are spot on
And dont even get me started on quantum mechanics and the fact that the darned photons go through BOTH SLOTS ! ;-)