Byron P. answered 07/15/21
Bar Exam and Law School Tutor With Decades of Teaching Experience
The 14th Amendment:
Procedural Due Process ("Due Procedures"/ "Procedures that are Due")
Fulfilled by:
(1) Adequate Notice (A statement of charges or claims and how to defend against them)
AND
(2) An Adequate Hearing (Proceedings commensurate with the claims and charges asserted in the Notice)
Examples:
> A Speeding Ticket: You don't get a jury. Sometimes not even a Judge, just a Hearing Officer. The Rules of Criminal Procedure?- No. The Rules of Evidence?- Only a few, mostly at the Hearing Officer's unfettered discretion.
> Capital Murder: A Jury Trial?- yes. The Rules of Criminal Procedure and the Rules of Evidence?- yes. Self Incrimination?- Never permitted unless waived. An Appeal as a Matter of Right?- Yes. Habeas Corpus? Perhaps unless the Writ is suspended, etc. The Right to Confront (cross-examine)- Yes. Discovery?- Yes and of every possible kind. A Preliminary Hearing? Yes. The Right to Suppress questionably obtained evidence?- Yes. A Speedy Trial?- Yes. Appointment of Counsel at the State's Expense?- Depends on your Financial Statement.
Substantive Due Process:
A guarantee of essential (fundamental) rights.
A right to be free of governmental conduct that "Shocks the Conscience".
Equal Protection (of the Laws): Not to be confused with Selective Enforcement.10 cars speeding- one officer in one radar-equipped squad car can't pull all of them over. One, perhaps two, is the best he/she can do.
The Personal Liberty Interest: Suggests freedom of movement (and freedom of thought and conduct) unrestrained by the actions of government and therefore a privacy right. One of several aspects of the U.S. Constitution composing the Penumbra in Roe v. Wade (1973).
Jurisprudence: Overall, the 14th Amendment is the pipeline through which the U.S. Constitution is applied to the states.
Query?- How else, but through the 14th Amendment, can the 13th Amendment abolition of slavery be applied to the States and State Actors?