The question you tried to load has been merged into the question below

Asked • 03/16/19

Particles for all forces: how do they know where to go, and what to avoid?

Here's an intuitive problem which I can't get around, can someone please explain it? Consider a proton P and an electron E moving through the electromagnetic field (or other particles for other forces, same argument). They exert a force upon one another. In classical mechanics this is expressed as their contributing to the field and the field exerts a force back upon them in turn. In quantum mechanics the model is the exchange of a particle. Let's say one such particle X is emitted from P and heads towards E. In the basic scenario, E absorbs it and changes its momentum accordingly. Fine. How does X know where E is going to be by the time it arrives? What's to stop E dodging it, or having some other particle intercept X en route? Are P and E emitting a constant stream of force-carrying particles towards every other non-force-carrying particle in the universe? Doesn't this imply a vast amount of radiation all over the place? I am tempted to shrug of the entire particle exchange as a mere numerical convenience; a discretization of the Maxwell equations perhaps. I am reluctant to say "virtual particle" because I suspect that term means something different to what I think it means. Or is it a kind of observer effect: E "observes" X in the act of absorbing it, all non-intercepting paths have zero probability when the waveform collapses? Or have I missed the point entirely?

Kristopher G.

The particles have no energy, and so yes there are a number of particles going in all directions all the time. They cover a certain surface area and as the distance doubles the surface area goes up by radius squared so that’s why we have inverse square law for electromagnetism. Gravity is better described by a curvature of space time. Rather than virtual particles. The photon and graviton (if it exists is massless). The intermediating particles of the strong and week force are massive therefore they can only exist a short amount of time who is why those forces have limited range. I have a few degrees in physics but will admit quantum physics isn’t my strongest suit
Report

07/02/19

2 Answers By Expert Tutors

By:

Rick R. answered • 07/31/19

Tutor
5.0 (508)

Electrical engineering specialist, MSEE degree, EE practitioner

Carlos B. answered • 03/16/19

Tutor
5.0 (28)

Bacherlor of science in physics

Still looking for help? Get the right answer, fast.

Ask a question for free

Get a free answer to a quick problem.
Most questions answered within 4 hours.

OR

Find an Online Tutor Now

Choose an expert and meet online. No packages or subscriptions, pay only for the time you need.