G C.

asked • 08/25/14

A horizontal force keeps a 2.0 kg box in equilibrium on a 60-degree incline; what is the magnitude of the horizontal force, and what is the normal force?

Please show this using an x-axis that is parallel to the incline, and please show again using an x-axis that is horizontal.
 
Thank you.
 

G C.

I am the asker of this question.  My textbook's published answer matches Kirill's answer.  I needed to understand the calculations, while my textbook only gives the answer (not the solution).  Thank you for your help, Kirill and others.
 
Report

08/25/14

Kirill Z.

Any time, you are welcome.
Report

08/25/14

3 Answers By Expert Tutors

By:

Phillip R. answered • 08/25/14

Tutor
New to Wyzant

Top Notch Math and Science Tutoring from Brown Univ Grad

Kirill Z.

Normal force is not correct.
Report

08/25/14

Phillip R.

yes, I neglected the component from the horizontal force. Shows the value of drawing a picture which I didn't do the first time.
Report

08/25/14

Francisco E. answered • 08/25/14

Tutor
5 (1)

Francisco; Civil Engineering, Math., Science, Spanish, Computers.

Kirill Z.

Normal force is wrong.
Report

08/25/14

Kirill Z. answered • 08/25/14

Tutor
4.8 (230)

Ph. D. in Physics with 4+ years of tutoring and teaching experience

Stephen K.

The only external force acting on the box is the gravitational force Fg = m·g = (2kg)·(9.8 m/s²) = 19.6 N or approx. 20 N.  The other forces arise as vector component of this mg force and cannot exceed  this value!
 
With the x-axis horizontal then the normal force N = mg·cos(60°) = 9.8 N
 
and, the force parallel to the slope Fll = mg·sin(60°) = 17 N
 
This can be verified by Pythagorean Theorem:  N² + Fll² = (mg)²
 
The numerical results for the case where the slope is horizontal should yield the same results, as mg is still the only external force acting on the system.
Report

08/25/14

Kirill Z.

It is clearly stated that there is a horizontal force acting on the box. This is also external force, be it from a person or from electrical field. Please, read the problem statement again.
Report

08/25/14

Stephen K.

Apologies, you are correct.
Report

08/25/14

Kirill Z.

Accepted, no problem. Best regards.
Report

08/25/14

Still looking for help? Get the right answer, fast.

Ask a question for free

Get a free answer to a quick problem.
Most questions answered within 4 hours.

OR

Find an Online Tutor Now

Choose an expert and meet online. No packages or subscriptions, pay only for the time you need.