David W. answered 09/18/16
Tutor
4.7
(90)
Experienced Prof
There are five bales of hay. Label them A,B,C,D,E. Since we don’t yet know the weights of each, let’s assume the weights of A, B, C, D, and E are in order from lightest to heaviest.
When they are weighed in all combinations of two, there are ten weights [PLZ note: “all combinations of two”].
This means that each bale was weighed four times (once with each other bale). The ten combinations are AB, AC, AD, AE, BC, BD, BE, CD, CE, DE [note: for example, AC is the same as CA].
So, the sum of the given weights is four times the total weight of the five bales:
(80+82+83+84+85+86+87+88+90+91) = 856
4(A+B+C+D+E) = 856
(A+B+C+D+E) = 214 [eq1]
We assumed A-E was lightest to heaviest, so:
A+B = 80 [eq2]
A+C = 82 [eq3]
A+D = 83 [eq4]
A+E = 84 [eq5]
B+C = 85 [eq6]
B+D = 86 [eq7]
B+E = 87 [eq8]
C+D = 88 [eq9]
C+E = 90 [eq10]
D+E = 91 [eq11]
Now, substitute pairs:
(A+B+C+D+E) = 214 [eq1 again]
((A+B)+(C+D)+E) = 214
( 80 + 88 + E ) = 214 [substitute using eq2 and eq9]
168 + E = 214
E = 46
… and use appropriate eq[s] for the others to find that:
D = 44
C = 43
B = 42
A = 38
Now, check that the total of A-E is 214.
Note: there is no other solution.
When they are weighed in all combinations of two, there are ten weights [PLZ note: “all combinations of two”].
This means that each bale was weighed four times (once with each other bale). The ten combinations are AB, AC, AD, AE, BC, BD, BE, CD, CE, DE [note: for example, AC is the same as CA].
So, the sum of the given weights is four times the total weight of the five bales:
(80+82+83+84+85+86+87+88+90+91) = 856
4(A+B+C+D+E) = 856
(A+B+C+D+E) = 214 [eq1]
We assumed A-E was lightest to heaviest, so:
A+B = 80 [eq2]
A+C = 82 [eq3]
A+D = 83 [eq4]
A+E = 84 [eq5]
B+C = 85 [eq6]
B+D = 86 [eq7]
B+E = 87 [eq8]
C+D = 88 [eq9]
C+E = 90 [eq10]
D+E = 91 [eq11]
Now, substitute pairs:
(A+B+C+D+E) = 214 [eq1 again]
((A+B)+(C+D)+E) = 214
( 80 + 88 + E ) = 214 [substitute using eq2 and eq9]
168 + E = 214
E = 46
… and use appropriate eq[s] for the others to find that:
D = 44
C = 43
B = 42
A = 38
Now, check that the total of A-E is 214.
Note: there is no other solution.
David W.
WyzAnt Answers Forum doesn't give subject grade level or other info; just history. Since the problem used the word "combinations" twice, I looked for that info. Many real-life problems have "faster, better, cheaper" solutions.
p.s., I've learned lots from you.
Report
09/18/16
Mark M.
09/18/16