Tom K. answered 04/25/21
Knowledgeable and Friendly Math and Statistics Tutor
Just to make the math a little easier, consider the points on the ellipse to be (cos theta, √3 sin theta)
Then, we minimize their distance squared from (-1, 0) - incidentally, a point on the ellipse, is
(cos theta - -1)^2 + (√3 sin theta)^2 =
cos^2 theta + 2 cos theta + 1 + 3 sin^2 theta = (substituting sin^2 theta + cos^2 theta = 1)
2 + 2 cos theta + 2 sin^2 theta
The derivative is
-2 sin theta + 4 sin theta cos theta =
-2 sin theta (2 cos theta - 1)
This equals 0 at sin theta = 0 or cos theta = 1/2, which gives us values of 0°, 180°, 60°, 300°
If we rewrite the first derivative as - 2 sin theta + 2 sin 2 theta, the second derivative is
-2 cos theta + 4 cos 2 theta
At 0°, 180°, 60°, 300°, we get
2, 6, -3, -3
Thus, we have relative minima at 0°, 180° and relative maxima at 60°, 300°
Clearly, given the nature of the function, the global minima and maxima will be among these four locations.
Also, clearly, 180° is the global minimum, as it is at the actual point. 60° and 300° gives the same value of the distance squared, so they will each be maxima.
(cos theta, √3 sin theta) at 60°, 300° is (1/2, 3/2) and (1/2, -3/2)