Hi Jonathan!
Great question! This is a classic application of put-call parity, which establishes a relationship between the prices of European call and put options with the same underlying asset, strike price, and expiration date.
Let's prove the result step by step.
Step 1: Write the put-call parity equation
For European options on a non-dividend-paying stock:
[
C+Ke^{-rT}=P+S_0
]
Where:
- (C) = Call option price
- (P) = Put option price
- (S_0) = Current stock price
- (K) = Exercise (strike) price
- (r) = Continuously compounded risk-free interest rate
- (T) = Time remaining until expiration
Rearranging:
[
C-P=S_0-Ke^{-rT}
]
Step 2: Use the information given
The question tells us that the call and put have identical prices.
Therefore:
[
C=P
]
This means:
[
C-P=0
]
Substituting into put-call parity:
[
0=S_0-Ke^{-rT}
]
Therefore:
[
\boxed{S_0=Ke^{-rT}}
]
Step 3: Determine which option is in the money
Assuming the risk-free interest rate is positive and the options have not yet expired:
[
r>0,\qquad T>0
]
Therefore:
[
e^{-rT}<1
]
Multiplying by the positive strike price:
[
Ke^{-rT}<K
]
But we already established:
[
S_0=Ke^{-rT}
]
Consequently:
[
\boxed{S_0<K}
]
Now recall the definitions:
Call option:
A call is in the money when:
[
S_0>K
]
Put option:
A put is in the money when:
[
S_0<K
]
Since we proved that (S_0<K):
[
\boxed{\text{The PUT option is in the money.}}
]
The call option is out of the money.
Step 4: Numerical example
Suppose:
- Strike price = $100
- Risk-free interest rate = 5%
- Time to expiration = 1 year
Using our result:
[
S_0=100e^{-0.05}
]
[
S_0\approx $95.12
]
Since:
[
95.12<100
]
the put option is in the money.
Its intrinsic value is:
[
100-95.12=$4.88
]
Meanwhile, the call option is out of the money because the stock price is below the strike price.
Even though the two options have the same market price, their intrinsic values do not have to be equal.
That's because an option's market price also reflects its time value.
Final Answer
Using put-call parity:
[
C-P=S_0-Ke^{-rT}
]
Since (C=P):
[
S_0=Ke^{-rT}
]
For a positive risk-free rate and positive time to maturity:
[
S_0<K
]
Therefore:
[
\boxed{\text{The put option is in the money.}}
]
Important assumption: This conclusion applies to European options on a non-dividend-paying stock when the risk-free interest rate is positive.
If the underlying asset pays dividends, put-call parity must be adjusted, and the conclusion can change.
Key takeaway: Two options can have the same market price even though one is in the money and the other is out of the money. Put-call parity helps us determine which one!
Hope this helps!
Michael