Joe C. answered 03/12/15
Tutor
New to Wyzant
Experienced Tutor with CFA Designation and BA in Finance
Assuming "amount of return" is referring to the return in dollars we want to calculate A for each and then subtract the original investment:
Jimmy:
A = 2,000(1+(.1/12))12*4 = 2,000(1.49) = 2980 Return = 2980 - 2000 = $980
Jenny:
A = 2,000(1+(.05/12))12*8 = 2,000(1.49) = 2980 Return = 2980-2000 = $980
Both Jimmy and Jenny make a return of $980. Ask yourself though, who made the better investment?