Because of the withdrawal on 01/01/2015, we have to break this down into 2 distinct calculations:
PV = (23,517.60)/1.025 = 22,944 Pounds Sterling
Then, we add back the 1,000 Pounds Sterling that was withdrawn exactly 1 year prior, to get: 23,944 Pounds Sterling
Carol had deposited the annual interest for exactly 1 year (2.5%) less than the value of 23,944 Pounds Sterling
So: PV (of 01/01/2014) is: (23,944/1.025) = 23,360
So, on 01/01/2014, Carol initially deposit 23,360 Pounds Sterling into a bank account earning 2.5% APR.