
Bill H. answered 04/12/17
Tutor
5
(32)
Patient and Experienced Tutor in Math, Communication and Computing
The key clue here is that the resulting curve must be differentiable, i.e., the slope of the lines on either side of the connection point at (-1, 3) must have the same slope. Having resolved the value of c as +4, in the third piece, we can differentiate that piece. We should then get:
f'(x) = 3x2 - 4 when x > -1
Therefore, at x = -1
f'(-1) = 3 - 4 = -1
The first piece of the function has two parameters to be resolved, a and b. If we evaluate the function at the point (-1, 3), we get:
f(-1) = a(-1)2 + b(-1) = a - b = 3
so
a = b + 3
If we differentiate the function's first branch, we get:
f'(x) = 2ax + b
and we need to set that to -1 at x = -1 to have the curve continuous and differentiable at the join.
So we now have two equations for the first piece of the function:
-2a + b = -1
a = b + 3
this will give us b = -5 and so a = -2
Placing these values into the equations, we get the full function being:
f(x) = -2x2 - 5x when x < -1
= 3 when x = -1
= x3 - 4 when x > -1
This should be differentiable with a slope of -1 at x = -1, and continuous through the point (-1, 3).
John B.
I suppose I have one quick question, I don't understand why the derivative of the function is not 0 when x=-1 as the derivative of 3 is zero.
Report
04/12/17

Bill H.
At exactly x = -1, there is a point, but it has zero width. Even though the differential uses infinitesimals, they are not actually quite zero. So any slope measured at x = -1 must include something an infinitesimal amount either side of (-1, 3).
Also, when you are moving along the line, the slope going into the point (-1, 3) will be -1, and going out of the point will be -1, so if the point has zero length, you can't tell that there was anything between the curves that wasn't allowed at -1.
Maybe not a great rationale, but it gets around the issue you raise!
Report
04/12/17

Bill H.
Sorry, 'allowed' should be 'sloped.' #$%@! spelling correctors!
Report
04/12/17
John B.
04/12/17