Asked • 06/26/19

Key choice for brass instruments?

I've been told several times that brass instruments prefer to play in keys with flats, rather than sharps. As a trumpet player myself, I cannot relate to this preference. E major is just as easy or hard as A flat major. I interpreted it as being the playing key, not the concert key.I'll take that the preference is true, since I've heard it from several trustworthy sources, but why is that? I have several hypotheses:1. Tradition. Bands (brass bands especially?) usually play in keys with flats, therefore that is what the players are used to, and more comfortable with. But how did the tradition start?2. Intonation. The construction of valve instruments make the intonation better in keys with flats. For example in A major: the low C# of the trumpet is naturally high, whereas a good intonation should have it low as the third of a major chord. I cannot think of a counterexample right now.I welcome guess answers, but please mention that you are just guessing if you do not actually know for a fact.

1 Expert Answer

By:

Armando R. answered • 12/30/19

Tutor
New to Wyzant

Composition for artist and musicians for the past 4 years

Still looking for help? Get the right answer, fast.

Ask a question for free

Get a free answer to a quick problem.
Most questions answered within 4 hours.

OR

Find an Online Tutor Now

Choose an expert and meet online. No packages or subscriptions, pay only for the time you need.