Matt G.

asked • 12/04/14

What is the limit as x approaches 0 of ( f(x^2+3x) divided by sin(x) ) ? Given that…(see description)

GIVEN:  f(x) is a differentiable function with the properties that the limit as x approaches 0 of f(x^2+3x) is 0 and the limit as x approaches 0 of f'(x^2+3x) is 4

1 Expert Answer

By:

Byron S. answered • 12/04/14

Tutor
5.0 (44)

Math and Science Tutor with an Engineering Background

Matt G.

Thank you so much for your response, Byron! This question was on a recent test given in my Calculus BC class. I got the answer 12 just as you did – L'hopital's and chain rule.  My teacher said it was wrong and that the correct answer was 4 because teacher believed that chain rule was already "accounted for" by the properties given — NOT TRUE because we do not know what f(x) is! Still, much of the class argued it was 4 until I found today a function that satisfies the given properties. f(x)=4sin(x) and also f(x)=4cos(x-(∏/2)).  If you do the limit question with either of these functions, you also get 12.  Can't wait to show the proof and thanks again!
Report

12/04/14

Byron S.

Depending on how exactly the problem was written, either could be correct. If the second limit had been written as
limx→0 d/dx [ f(x2+3x) ] = 4
then the chain rule would be accounted for, and the overall answer would be 4.
 
Regardless, you should not use the word of a semi-anonymous online math tutor as justification to publicly call out your teacher as wrong. It's clear that he intended the problem to mean what I wrote here, even if he may not have.
Report

12/04/14

Still looking for help? Get the right answer, fast.

Ask a question for free

Get a free answer to a quick problem.
Most questions answered within 4 hours.

OR

Find an Online Tutor Now

Choose an expert and meet online. No packages or subscriptions, pay only for the time you need.