Asked • 04/20/19

Why do we need У in "Ножка у сту́ла сломалась"?

In the sentence "Ножка у сту́ла сломалась" (the chair leg broke), why do we need the у? The genitive case on "стул" already lets you know that it's the *chair's* leg that's broken. More generally, when and why is у used to indicate posession in Russian rather than simply using the genitive case? By the way, I'm aware that "сту́ла" is already in the genitive, I'm asking why у is there as well.

2 Answers By Expert Tutors

By:

Yelena F. answered • 10/11/19

Tutor
5.0 (852)

12+ years of experience in teaching Russian

Michael S. answered • 05/18/19

Tutor
New to Wyzant

International Journalist & Educator, Guinness Book Fastest Typist

Yelena F.

One of the meanings of the preposition "Y" is "Included accessory" (appurtenance), for example, "крыша у нашего дома зелёная, а у наших соседей коричневая", and it is similar to using Genitive case "ножка стула" or "крыша дома". Both situations expressing possession/belonging to something as a part require a Genitive case, as well as after the preposition "y" - with any meaning of the sentence, the Genitive case is a must.
Report

10/11/19

Still looking for help? Get the right answer, fast.

Ask a question for free

Get a free answer to a quick problem.
Most questions answered within 4 hours.

OR

Find an Online Tutor Now

Choose an expert and meet online. No packages or subscriptions, pay only for the time you need.