Search 73,319 tutors
0 0

# Find the limit?

Find the limit of (sin(x+h)-sin(x))/h as h approaches 0.

Answer: cos x

Please show all your work.
Tutors, please sign in to answer this question.

### 2 Answers

Use the trig identity sin(x+h) = sin(x)cos(h) + cos(x)sin(h), so that

(sin(x+h)-sin(x))/h = (sin(x)(cos(h) - 1) + cos(x)sin(h))/h.

Now take the limit

limh→0 (sin(x)(cos(h) - 1) + cos(x)sin(h))/h = sin(x) limh→0 ((cos(h) - 1)/h) + cos(x) limh→0 (sin(h)/h).

From basic trigonometry it is known that

limh→0 ((cos(h) - 1)/h) = 0  and  limh→0 (sin(h)/h) = 1, so that

limh→0 (sin(x)(cos(h) - 1) + cos(x)sin(h))/h = cos(x).

### Comments

Thank you, Kenneth. This is the trigonometric proof that's needed in this problem.
Your approach to the problem is also very good too!
lim    (sin(x+h)-sin(x))/h
h→0

since sin(x+h) = sin(x) cos(h) + cos(x) sin(h)

then we have

lim   (sin(x) cos(h) + cos(x) sin(h) - sin(x))/h
h→0

grouping 1st and 3rd term, we have

lim    ((cos(h) - 1) sin(x) + cos(x) sin(h))/h
h→0

Since h not equal 0, a limit exist for the above function.

When h→0  cos(h)=1  and sin(h)=h, the above function becomes

lim   ((1-1)sin(x) + cos(x)(h))/h
h→0

lim   (0 + cos(x)h)/h
h→0

lim cos(x)h/h
h→0

cos(x)

---------------------
equation used in this exercise:

sin(a+b) = sin(a)cos(b) + cos(a)sin(b)

and

lim     cos(x)  = 1       ;     lim   sin(x)  =  x
x→0                                 x→0

applying equations and recognizing pattern of problem is key to solving this kind of math questions, which has been known for some hundreds of year!!!
I bet there is other ways to solve it!!

### Comments

limx→0sin(x) = 0, not x. However, limx→0(sin(x)/x) = 1.
sin(x) = x - x^3/3! + x^5/5! − x^7/7! + . . .

As x → 0 don't the cube and higher degree terms go to zero much faster than x?

So why can't you say as x → 0, sin(x) → x?

Don't we use the approximation sin(x) ≈ x near x = 0?
Steve,
The limit of a function f(x) is defined to be a number, not another function. We can't use an approximation in a proof.
(sin(x) - x) = - x^3/3! + x^5/5! − x^7/7! + . . .

As x → 0 the right side → 0, so the value of sin(x) - x → 0 and
sin(x) → x. It's asymptotic.
No, all this means is
limx→0sin(x) = limx→0x = 0.
Please review the ε-δ-definition of limit.

Also, using the Taylor series of sin(x) in this problem is circular, because to get to the Taylor series you need to take the derivative of sin(x), which is exactly what you are supposed to find in this problem.